"I wanted to love this product, but I don't. It went on clumpy and was hard to fix. After a short time, I had smudges under my eyes--a definite turn-off. I gave it three stars becaue the color was luscious--a pretty brown. I really love the way the color looks, brightens up my green eyes. However, I won't be buying again. I use another dept. store brand of mascara that is absolutely amazing--stayed on during a marathon! It does not smudge and comes off in tiny clumps later when I wash my face, does not smudge at all. If Origins comes up with a product like that, I will happily try it. I feel like I want all of my skin care and cosmetics to be from Origins because I love what they stand for. The skin care has me 100%, but I'm not quite there with the make up."